
Should Your Writing Entertain? Entertaining vs. Artistic. When I first planted a church in 2002 I was bivocational. But I wasn’t a writer yet. I was a voice teacher in a musical theater program (or theatre if you’re fancy like we were at Illinois Wesleyan University). And there were some unwritten rules in the musical theater world at the time.
One of them was that Andrew Lloyd Webber wasn’t a series composer. He was often compared and contrasted with Stephen Sondheim.
Webber’s shows, Cats, Phantom of the Opera, Joseph and Technicolored Dreamcoat, were simply too popular.
The average uncultured tourist to New York City didn’t know any better but to love what they loved and sell out those shows night after night…
after night…
after night…
Meanwhile, Stephen Sondheim was a genius. Cultured. Difficult.
He was also successful, but his audiences were more refined.
Serious.
Cultured.
I remember researching repertoire to teach my students, and the internet told me that no one does Webber for auditions. Makes them look amateur.
But then again, no one does Sondheim either. Might risk getting a subpar accompanist who will ruin your audition.
Furthermore, who do you think you are, doing Sondheim at your age? How could you possibly be that sophisticated?!
Aaaaaanywaaaaaaaayyyyy…
I then went on staff at the church we planted and left the biz for about twenty years.
Then I came back in 2022 for a couple of years to teach in the same program.
And everything had changed. Sondheim still enjoyed the godlike reputation and his pedestal was up as high as it always had been (and should be).
But…
So was Lloyd Webber!
And that delighted me. Because, do you know what? I really like his musicals. Do you know why? Because 99% of musicals our there bore me.
That’s right. I said it. Mostly because they stop the action for the song and dance. Come on, already! I’m sleepy!
But last summer a local theater here in my town did Joseph.
It was spectacular. First, it was well-cast and well-performed.
But before that, it was well-written. My goodness!
You can’t blink or you’ll miss something important.
The timing kept us on the edge of our seats and I’m sure my eyes were wide, my head was jutted forward, and my mouth was a big, wide, gaping, goofy smile.
Lloyd Webber gives me joy, because he never takes my attention for granted.
Don’t get me wrong. I do like Sondheim, and he deserves all the honor we give him, but I’m glad LW has been given his place. I’m glad that the students in 2022 when I went back to teach didn’t seem to know it wasn’t classy to like him.
Now…
My famous question: What’s that got to do with our writing as Christian writers?
If our message is important and lives and souls are at stake, we owe it to God to make our message as palatable as possible.
No, no, no, I don’t mean dumb down the truth or the gospel.
I just mean present the truth in the easiest way to digest.
Even be entertaining, if possible.
So here’s an exercise to make your writing more digestible.
Open a chapter you’re working on and ask this question:
Where am I asking the reader to wait while I get to the good part?
You know what I mean. Three paragraphs of introduction. A definition nobody asked for yet and an explanation of what you’re about to explain.
Meanwhile, somewhere down the page, there’s a person with a problem or a question you’d actually like answered.
Try starting there.
Then look for three things:
1. Give us something to wonder about.
You could begin, “Forgiveness is an important part of the Christian life.”
True.
But what about, “I had already forgiven him. Then he walked into the room.”
Now I want to know what happened.
You can teach me about forgiveness along the way.
2. Give us something we can see.
“He struggled with pride” tells us what to think about a person.
“He checked the church website three times to see whether they had added his name” lets us catch him in the act.
And possibly recognize ourselves.
Specifics give your ideas a body. A place to live. Someone’s hands to shake.
3. Keep moving.
Every paragraph should give the reader something: a development in the story, a clearer understanding, a laugh, a moment of recognition, a question that pulls them forward.
Read your chapter and ask, “What does this paragraph add?”
If you’ve already made the point, trust us. We got it. Take us somewhere else.
Now, spend fifteen minutes revising one page. Start closer to the interesting part. Replace one general statement with something we can picture. Cut a repetition.
Read it aloud.
Does it make you want to read the next page?
We can’t guarantee that everyone will love what we write. But we can give some thought to the experience we’re asking them to have.
Their attention is a gift.
Let’s give them something worth paying attention to.
Jeff B Miller
We've got the answers for your questions
Publishing can feel overwhelming, but you’re not alone. Here are answers to common questions—if you need more help, just reach out!
At Indie Christian Book, our difference is rooted in two core commitments:
Excellence in Editing: We take exceptional pride in our thorough editing process. Your manuscript undergoes multiple stages of careful refinement—structural, content, line, and proofreading—ensuring your book reaches readers in its most polished and powerful form. We believe that meticulous editing honors both your message and your readers.
Personalized Guidance: We recognize that each author's journey is unique. Rather than applying a one-size-fits-all approach, we partner closely with you to understand the specific purpose God has placed on your heart. Your book receives individualized attention tailored to your particular vision, audience, and ministry goals.
This combination of editorial excellence and personalized care ensures that your published work truly reflects both your voice and God's purpose for your writing.
The timeline varies based on your book’s needs, but most projects take 4-6 months from manuscript to publication.
Yes! We offer platform development, book launch strategy, and promotional support.
Each project is unique—contact us for a custom quote tailored to your publishing needs.
We publish a wide range of faith-based books, including:
- Teaching Materials
- Memoirs & Biographies
- Devotionals
- Biblical Studies
- Ministry Resources
- Christian Living
